I thought you loved that album?
Didn’t you throw a hisy fit when everyone started bagging it?
What don’t you like about it anyway?
(and I’m honstly curious and not taking the piss)
Well I’m not sure if your post is serious or not. I don’t remember throwing a “hissy fit”. I think the album is not as bad as people were making it out to be. I probably wouldn’t have criticized it on this board. Around here I tend to be supportive of Manson and keep the negativity to myself.
I just think they lost the songs are a bit bland and too “straightforward rock”. Twiggy is not the best guitar player. He plays the instrument like a bassist would. Good rhythm stuff but the leads are weak.
The programming/electronic end of the spectrum wasn’t too impressive. I don’t know how much freedom Vrenna was given, but I missed Pogo on keyboards. If anything I expected some insane programming from someone from the NIN camp, but it was quite generic and dull.
The themes and lyrics were too maudlin, even by Manson standards. A 40 year old goth pimp whining about the various cunts in his life doesn’t make for the best theme. And when Manson is in his “I’m dangerous” American boogeyman mode, it feels forced.
in his defense, I imagine it would be difficult to come up with topics to write about when you’re 40 and have been a successful rock star half your life. If the women in his life are his main concern, then he should write about them.
It’s easy to be some douche like Fennesz, hiding behind a computer making fart noises and everyone thinks you’re a genius. It’s harder to be someone like Manson who really made some great statements and had something to say and now his lifestyle is just not relevant to most of his fans, he’s out of touch, and it’s tough to connect with him.
At least it’s better than Rob Zombie, repeating his stupid mindless Halloween csmpy bullshit that is meaningless and the same cliche riffs and fist pumping crap.