Yeah he is fucking up really bad. I can tell you from being a member over at the (now defunct) MansonUSA that his fanbase is really waning as well. Many are alienated by his incoherent “performances”, weight shifts, drunken interviews, lack of promotion or communication with fans, just lack of giving a shit really…
The live setlists have been the more or less the same since Golden Age of Grotesque, with the only change being the addition of a few songs from the whatever current new album is which are then removed save for maybe 1 single the next time around. It’s like a greatest hits set list over and over when most of the people there are fans who have seen him before and want to hear b-sides and more variety.
Criticism was getting really high over there, to the point where each thread was full of bashing and people saying he needs rehab. The new album is good, and was well received by those who heard it, but everything surrounding it is a fucking mess and there was next to no promotion for it, guaranteeing a flop on the charts.
There were a few very vocal fans still in denial, constantly defending him, but even some of the diehards had started crossing over. I’ve always been critical. I think things have been going downhill in that world since right after ‘Holy Wood’, but now it’s really bad.
To be fair this weight thing started in 2004 during the Against All Gods (Best Of) tour. Then he shifted back to being relatively skinny up until this recent time. He’s got some serious issues and I don’t want to see him fill that rock star cliche but it certainly seems things are headed in that direction…Really scary.
I wouldn’t say most of the world hates him though. I think most just don’t care/don’t even know he’s still active as a performer. When I mention Manson to people (usually twenty-somethings) they often say “he’s a really smart guy” referring to Bowling for Columbine and “is he still around?”
I think the public perception of him has been relatively static post-Holy Wood era, with his visibility gradually diminishing with each album.
He could have been so much more and it’s obvious that it’s all getting to him.
Trent Reznor’s “dopey clown” quote was quite accurate, but I prefer “bloated clown”