I think what a I like about this Prongs group is people actually take a bit of thought and care into a topic like this. Other sites I’d likely get a bunch of juiced up machomen screaming, “Yeah, I wanna kill a bunch of people, huh huh huh!!!”
I pondered this question a bit over the day and I think that I would NOT want a magical button of death. The power to just go in my closet, push a button, and make someone die it’s just too much for me to take. There’s no COST for killing someone and that scares me. It’s just too damn easy and I don’t think taking a life should be easy.
I would kill someone, though, in the “you can get away with it” scenario. And taking the “even if you had to look the person in the face” stipulation a bit further I think I would kill someone ONLY if I could look them in the face. There are human bacteria and scum that come across the planet from time to time and I think if I could come to the point of rationalization where I have decided that this particular person either only brings hurt and devastation to the world or that the destruction caused by this person is irreprehensible and cannot be forgiven or overcompensated . . . .
Yes, I would put a gun in that person’s face and say, “Hi, my name is Gunnar. Your murderous and raping ways have brought pain and suffering to this world and you have been found to be unredeemable and unfit for this world. Today your life has been judged and I am here to take it!” and I would pull that trigger and wath his/her face get destroyed like a watermelon with an M-80 in it.
I have no idea what the psychological toll, if any, would be if I were to execute someone. But the people who would make their way onto my list are such that I am willing to deal with the side effects. Like I noted earlier, I don’t think killing should be “free” or easy.
I sometimes think about our so-called “justice system” and how there really isn’t a whole lot of justice most of the time. Instead we get a back-and-forth moral-high-ground ping pong match . . . . “It’s not the state’s right to play God! The death penalty is immoral!” . . . . “Eye for an Eye! Tooth for a tooth! Fry 'em all like fish!” And so the debates go on, ad infinitum and the death-penalty opponents say, “It doesn’t give justice to the victims.” Or they note that it does not provide peace to the survivors. But there’s just as many survivors that are haunted and horrified that such human scum is even allowed to sit in a 6 foot cage and get a meal every day.
I know it would never happen, but I love to think of ways to re-invent portions of our society and the justice system is one of those topics that I feel could use a bit more creativity, compassion, and imagination.
If someone raped and murdered my child, I would not only want the criminal dead, I would feel it is owed to me. I totally think we should give the power back to the victims of these crimes. If you are willing to look said cretin (I’m speaking of a tried and convicted, beyond-any-shadow-of-doubt guilty type of person) in the face and see into his/her eyes as you killl them and are willing to live with that, I say why not?