Throbbing Gristle Live Review

The show at the Masonic Temple in Brooklyn last night was insane. Did anyone else go?

It was a great mix of hipsters, old school avant garde types, authentic goths types and just general weirdos attending.

I think the sound people did a good job accommodating the acoustics of the stone structure for the most part. It’s really a gorgeous building.

We sat up in the balcony for ‘Shadow of the Sun’. I’d never seen the film itself, only heard TG’s soundtrack. It’s a psychedelic art film and seems to be set in a post-apocalyptic world after a nuclear war (my interpretation).

TG came out with little fanfare, but the place went nuts. They proceeded to hunch over their gear and the film began to play on a projector over them as the house lights dimmed.

The soundtrack they performed was radically different from the one previously released and was just breathtaking. It started with a deep, throbbing drone that had the whole place vibrating, building up in pitch slowly to this screaming, unnerving train wreck of sound. Then the piece softened back down again and arabic synths emerged playing strange, haunting melodies, The piece continued to ebb and flow, softening up again before launching into a third movement, characterized by bizarre pitch shifted female vocal harmonies in multiple octaves.

The place erupted in applause when they were done and it seemed like we had been in a time warp as the house lights came back on for the signing. I had bought a new t-shirt for the tour along with a new CD available only for the tour so I decided to get that signed. It was bizarre, like waiting in line to meet the Industrial equivalent of the Beatles.

I couldn’t muster a word when Genesis, Peter, Chris and Cosey were signing my CD. Genesis is downright unnerving up close. (S)he just looks amazing. Awesome bizarre vintage clothes. Fingers bedecked with strange gold rings that looked like eyeballs. Half painted cracked orange fingernails. Truly a unique individual…like a modern day homeless transvestite sorcerer or something.

Cosey refused to sign my friend’s vinyl copy of The First Annual Report. All she said was “This is a bootleg”. (What is the deal with that anyway? Does anyone know? I thought it was official, but released after the 2nd and 3rd Annual Reports for some reason). My girlfriend had nothing for them to sign but a train schedule and Cosey laughed at that. Genesis looked at her and remarked that this was the best thing (s)he had signed all night. Eventually the crowd thinned and the signing was done. TG returned backstage and people waited with anticipation for their next performance, which would consist of songs throughout their catalog.

What followed was really confusing. A a simple throbbing syncopated synth note started playing on the speakers and gradually got louder, doubled, tripled and so on with delay. As this was happening a vertical bar of light appeared on the projection screen, growing more and more bright. Then another horizontal bar appeared, forming a cross shape. The house lights went out. The long and short of this is that this tedious, extremely loud display continued for about thirty minutes as a confused audience stood still, presumably all thinking what I was thinking; that this was some kind of intro for TG to retake the stage. The lights continued to strobe in simple flashing patterns that never led anywhere. No culmination and the noise was just this pulse repeated ad nauseum, building up with effects, and reducing back down, over and over. Finally it stopped and the house lights went on. People were extremely confused and several were shouting “assholes!” from the balcony, to which TG’s douchey stage manager responded with a middle finger and by flashing the set list to indicate that they would indeed play another set of material.

I was convinced this was some kind of audience experiment and that TG were sticking to their roots and had decided to provoke this new generation of fans. it turned out that some other guy was on the bill to perform and I guess was playing this monotonous crap from the back of the auditorium, so what most people thought was a bloated, tedious intro for the band gone far too long was actually someone else’s “performance”. It was the least enjoyable experimental live performance I have ever seen.

Finally TG took the stage and all of the house and stage lights were on. Genesis said a few words to the crowd and people were ecstatic. This band really is important to their cult-like following. I think one of their greatest legacies will be the mystique they were able to build around themselves, carefully cultivating legendary status even when they were first active.

Their first song was “Very Friendly” and, like all the others, it has been radically updated to match the digital post-industrial sound they’ve perfected with 2007’s ‘Part Two: The Endless Not’. Chris Carter’s deep, pulsing beat provided the undercurrent for the sonic maelstrom conjured by the band. Cosey Fanni Tutti resembled a senior member of Sunn 0))) in her black robe, injecting bursts of distortion from a modified slide guitar. Peter Christopherson was playing what looked like a flip phone that he flapped open and closed to create piercing digital static, and Orridge delivered a spoken word piece about murderers Ian Brady and Myra Hindley that was restrained at first, but broke to a manic pitch as the song progressed, with Orridge shouting the words and rocking back and forth.

The exact setlist isn’t clear in my mind. The atmosphere was intense and there was a lot of energy in the air. They played subterranean beat-driven material I’d never heard or didn’t recognize next. “Hamburger Lady” followed, completely updated and barely recognizable save for the lyrics. Gurgling drones filled the low end and the high synth notes were played by P. Orridge on some kind of horn. Other songs included a haunting rendition of “Almost a Kiss” and the title track from ‘Part Two: The Endless Not’ as well as more beat-driven material I didn’t recognize. One jam in particular was incredible, with Cosey ditching the slide guitar for a small horn and Peter alternating to a seated instrument to lay sound over a shifting, clicking Industrial groove. The band closed with an energetic, completely updated version of “Discipline”. Orridge was pacing around, yelling into the mic as the crowd throbbed up and down, proving that the band is still energetic and vital after all these years.

The only issues were some scattered sound problems. Orridge was playing an electric violin during one song which was barely audible, if at all. After another song, there was loud feedback after they stopped playing and it took the sound guy a minute to discover the source of the problem. Cosey displayed visible pain and Genesis stopped the set for a minute to make sure she was all right. Finally, there seemed to be an ongoing argument between the band and their manager about dimming the house lights, which were on throughout the show.

Regardless, the band was absolutely amazing live. Their Industrial sound has been completely modernized to match the digital age and they are perhaps as relevant as ever, creating psychedelic dance music from the future that sounds as fresh as their sonic experimental techniques did in the late 1970s.

They are playing a completely different setlist tonight at Le Poisson Rouge and I opted to see them again because they were so fucking good and this is such a limited opportunity. I can’t wait!

EDIT: Also the new CD they were selling is called ‘The Third Mind Movements’ and I’m listening to it now. I’ll post more about it and tonight’s show later!

Top notch review dude.

These shows sound fantastic.

Thanks for the info. I’ll be sure not to bring First Annual Report (and I was honestly considering that too, just because it’s small and wouldn’t be at much risk of damage).

Good review.

How long was the TG performance in total? Interesting that they meet with fans with most of their performance still to go. Or is that what they usually do? The only stories I can think of TG performances (of years ago) are ones involving self mutilation and vomiting on stage (which are probably exaggerated).

Top notch review dude.

These shows sound fantastic.

Yeah you would really have liked the more beat driven stuff. Deep bass pulses and industrial beats like some caveman digital shit with crazy sounds over the top and not in a boring techno context at all. I hope they release some of that on their next CD.

Thanks voidhead, that review was excellent. Hopefully this tour will be documented so those that missed it can see what it was like.

[reply]Top notch review dude.

These shows sound fantastic.

Yeah you would really have liked the more beat driven stuff. Deep bass pulses and industrial beats like some caveman digital shit with crazy sounds over the top and not in a boring techno context at all. I hope they release some of that on their next CD.[/reply]

Yeah that sounds filthy!

Long live TG!

Great review, now I’m in the mood for some TG. An updated Hamburger Lady? sounds f’n sick

High Five!

Yeah the old songs are radically updated and sound fucking GREAT! It would be cool for them to release a CD documenting the updated versions.

If you go to their myspace you can hear a snippet of an updated “Xyclon B Zombie” which I’m hoping they play tonight.

Here’s some photos and video:

http://poptartssucktoasted.blogspot.com/2009/04/throbbing-gristle-brooklyn-masonic.html

1002

here’s an aricle from the village voice on the show w/a video… the guy totally got it wrong for his review

http://blogs.villagevoice.com/music/archives/2009/04/live_throbbing.php

I was actually standing by why they rejected signigng the album. Like it mattered… it was a total clusterfuck getting shit signed… you couldn’t really talk to the band, they just signed shit and passed it between themselves and handed it back before people had a chance to really talk to them.
The bass in that place is the loudest and deepest i’ve ever heard in my life. All the thick stone walls just bounced the low end right back.
they sold shirts for 20, cds for 15, patches and pins fro 10. a ll of which were limited edition. the cds of only 1000 printed i think it was, and the pins like 300… the cds were gone pretty fast too. I felt kinda bad buying 2 but fuck it

apparently foetus was at the show too, i heard a bunch of people mention talking to him.
I got there really early and actualyl got to watch most of the soundchack. then i just kinda walked around the venue and wound up in the bands dressing room. I saw all their shit hanging up and a big deli tray with fruits and those cookies with that are square qithe the little chocolate pictures in the middle… had i been less of a decent human being i could have totally grabbed their shit since nobody was around. Didn’t cross my mind even at the time though… not like i would… i just was putzing around the place looking at all the rooms in the basement of a masonic temple. wonder what kind of weird shit’s gone on in there over the years.
I lucked out and was stage right for all 3 sets, against the stage in front on gen. But during the last one something i couldn’t take it anymore and had to move back. It was weird. I’m normally kinda into like meditation and visualization and shit and all yesterday at the place it’s like my radar was off the charts and i was getting these intense intense visuals and I honestly didn’t kow if I was even going to make it through to the end of the show (I did). Plus i have like, agoraphobia and bad social anxiety. thankfully they only did and hour each time they played.

overall the crowd had to have been some of the most diverse, nice people so it was a little helpful. except this one like bald headed gay dude who threatened me thinking i was trying to cut him in line when all i did was lean against a fucking pole cause my back hurt. but im rambling. id go tonight, but i mean, i got the ticket for last night and then also the next show at the same place which is the last date of the tour, and i can’t keep tossing out money on all these shows and cds and whatnot. But being in front of gen seeing (s)he flipping out screaming “and thinner and thinner and thinner” during the first song was definately etched in my had for life. and he hda this bottle that (s)he used to play bass with that was all adorned with these beautiful jewels and stuff. too bad they didn’t videotape the whole show for release… just audio

^ That was the most self-absorbed, retarded “review” I have ever read. The reviewer basically reveals more about the fact that he is a douchebag (stealing the band’s food?!?) than he does about the show itself.

^ That was the most self-absorbed, retarded “review” I have ever read. The reviewer basically reveals more about the fact that he is a douchebag (stealing the band’s food?!?) than he does about the show itself.

i didn’t steal their food… i was just rambling on a tangent and mentioned wandering around the place and how i found myself in their dressing room. you had the review… i just talked about some shit more or less

lol I’m sorry I thought you were saying that you what you wrote was actually the review from the village voice.

After reading the review, I agree it was shit. First off they did not play “Zyclon B Zombie” and secondly the reviewer seems to believe the band’s sole purpose was to provoke people. God forbid people enjoy themselves!

When I watch the classic live video of “Discipline” I see plenty of people bouncing and enjoying themselves.

it’s all good… so how was it compared to the show the next night?

Honestly i think the guy from the voice probably fell asleep and/or left during the second set and just made shit up for the 3rd…

you going to the one on the 28th too?

awesome review voidhead, thanks alot for going into such detail. sounds amazing.

ere is my review for 4/17/09:

We arrived late to Le Poisson Rouge, which is a small club venue. The concert was more intimate and the sound was better overall. It was a more complete mix where Chris’ pulsing drum loops and Genesis’ vocals had been the dominant elements the night before, which made the textural sounds laid over the beats all the more hypnotic this time around.

We came in halfway through “Hamburger Lady”. The set list was similar, with the same beat-driven jams that I had heard the previous night and the songs “Almost a Kiss”, “Endless Not”, “What a Day” and “Discipline” as the closing song. I have heard elsewhere that “Persuasion” was added to the setlist, but must have been played before we arrived along with “Very Friendly”.

Genesis at one point spoke a few of the lyrics from “Something Came Over Me” and joked with the crowd “I wonder what it was?” which got some laughs. The audience was more vocal during this performance. People were repeatedly shouting for songs to be played. I heard one guy shout “Slug Bait!” and a girl near me was jumping up and down, screaming “We need discipline!”

I talked to Genesis P. Orridge an hour after the show when we happened to walk by again. (S)he was standing outside of Le Poisson Rouge, wearing a leather jacket. I asked about the set list being roughly the same as the night before. I was personally disappointed because a promoter at the Masonic Temple had advertised the set as being completely different.

Genesis said “This is the first time we’ve played together in over a year”

I’m interested to see how the set list and live performance evolves as they continue this mini-tour. I asked about a follow up to ‘Part Two: The Endless Not’, but the answer was obscured by some people shouting behind us. I didn’t want to ask Genesis to repeat what (S)he’d said because other people were approaching.

The last question I got in before I was interrupted was “How do you feel about the introduction of “Industrial” music to the mainstream in the nineties with artists like Nine Inch Nails etc.?”

(S)he shrugged and said “It’s like Jazz. There are many different forms. Some people become obsessive with certain aspects of the sound and they explore those and we continue to do what we do…”

I am left satisfied. I enjoyed the concerts I attended even though the set lists were similar. i got to meet someone who has been a profound influence on me and talk for a minute, something that was impossible to accomplish at the previous night’s signing given the big crowd. What they are doing feels earnest. That’s all that matters to me.

picked up tix for the 2ns chicago show.

although i have heard random songs by them here and there, i’m not the most familiar with their catalog. i just can’t pass up a chance to see a show like this, especially when it’s a band like TG. I am excited.

I miss everything good.

Fuck, man.

[laugh]

Here’s a pretty solid recordings of the San Francisco show:

http://theebradmiller.blogspot.com/2009/04/throbbing-gristle-live-in-san-francisco_28.html

I also found one for the Chicago show, but the sound quality left a lot to be desired. The SF recording will hold me over until they inevitably release all the US shows in a fancy-pants CD wallet with a high price tag.
Chicago was a really great show, and it was cool to hear how they updated their sound. It’s hard to pick a favorite moment, but Very Friendly has always been a favorite of mine, and the live version was intense. I’d write a longer review, but Voidhead summed it up pretty thoroughly.
On a side note, I finally got my autographed poster back from the framing shop. Looks great on a wall.