This album is definitely a grower and tops both ‘Golden Age’ and ‘Eat Me Drink Me’ IMO because there is a lot more variation. Musically it’s very ‘Mechanical Animals’ meets ‘Eat Me Drink Me’ with a hint of ‘Holy Wood’.
I think the lyrics and theme are what really bring it down. More whining about fucked up relationships and threats against exes that just seem sad and pathetic. (“You said you’d be with me forever and you left me so I’m going to kill you to fulfill your promise” kind of thing…)
The thing to think about is, though, that this theme is actually very honest. It’s not a put on. You can feel the passion in what he says. And even if it’s juvenile (especially at his age), it’s sincere. I think he’s become so self-absorbed and dependent on substances that he feels victimized by all of the other people in his life. I’m not saying I admire this, but honest emotion in lyrics is something I value, even if I disagree with the sentiment behind it.
But the music is quite good on a lot of tracks. I’d say the standouts are (in order of appearance)
“Pretty as a Swastika”
“Arma-Goddamn-Mother-Fuckin-Geddon”
“Blank and White”
“I Want to Kill You Like They Do in the Movies”
“WOW”
“I Have to Look Up Just to See Hell”
“Into the Fire”
So IMO about half or more of the album is very solid after a few listens. None of the other songs are terrible.
As for the latest tour footage. Yes he is a complete mess. Wasted on absinthe and coke, the former being the worse problem IMO because he is just too drunk to pull it together. Forgetting lyrics, stopping songs mid-song, completely out of key. He really has become a rock 'n roll cliche.
This further proves the honesty of this album and that the character Marilyn Manson is not a put-on. He really is this fucked up person and I think he has become the monster he made and it’s destroying him. He’s so wrapped up in this persona and self-destructing.
He’s been on a bad track since he lost Dita. I think they really cared for each other and he fucked it up. I believe Twiggy is an enabler and that has something to do with it (he was one of the people in the room at “6 am Christmas morning” as Manson sings on the first track of ‘Eat Me Drink Me’)
He needs rehab desperately.
The thing with Trent is that they have fought and made up several times, the last being when Manson directed and appeared in the vid for “Starfuckers Inc” and they performed the song live together in MSG during the Fragility tour. Trent is usually the one who lashes out at and mocks Manson in press. I think he is more of an asshole in real life than Manson to be honest.
Like a typical recovering addict, his comments about Manson have a condescending edge, holier than thou. He is spot on that Manson needs help, but if he was really a friend he wouldn’t be spouting off about it in a major publication. It’s not like he reached out to Manson in private. So his whole statement is basically a new way for him to continue to shit on Manson in the press but seem like a good guy despite it.