No. It did progress into stuff like Wolf Eyes, Sightings, Prurient, Hair Police, Sword Heaven and other artists generally labelled as “Noise” but who are performing actual compositions and not just improvisations when they play live.
Industrial is supposed to be dark, angry, and alienating. That’s why none of you like modern Industrial except for Peligro. These artists did a good job alienating all the people who jumped on the bandwagon with Industrial Rock and EBM in the 90’s.
OK, I had a long day at work yesterday so I’m slacking a little today so will go into a bit of a rant, for those who don’t enjoy rants please read no further.
I listened to my share of noise and made my share of it too back in the tape trading glory days. These days noise is not alienating to me, it’s just boring. When something “alienating” has been done for almost 30 years is it still alienating? Nothing that your band, or my old projects, or Wolf Eyes, or Whitehouse or any of 'em do is going to have the impact that Throbbing Gristle did no matter how many times we scream about “Mohammad Being A Terrorist”
That’s because TG blew the lids off of people’s expectations and it made people mad because they were doing things “wrong”. There was no genre to define what they did early on, it was pure, mad chaos that took aspects of the past and glued them together in the context of a vast and strange rock band that did everything wrong. “Industrial” came later. It was a tag journalists used to try and define this weirdness. “True industrial” is absurd because almost none of the originators of the “sound” like the term industrial at all.
Once the genre name got bandied about by journalists, other bands wanting the same journalists’ interest started proclaiming themselves “industrial” in order to get noticed.
Really in many ways TG were the cultural mash-up of avant composers such as Stockhausen, rock bands like the Velvet Underground, fringe writers such as William S. Burroughs and freak culture the likes of which Jerry Springer and his ilk love to feature. It was, at the time, a unique blen but now that dish has been cooked, served and eaten - we’ve all dined at that table. We can make it again, it may be better cooked, delivered in a more garish or tasteful container, but it will never be as shockingly new as it was when TG made it.
Eat the food you like, love the music you love, but this constant bickering about the “true way” is boring. If you need your music to be better than other people’s in order to like it there’s a good chance you don’t actually like the music you like and you’re simply using it as a crutch to hold you up.