I’m the opposite, when I started playing bass in my 20s I started to realize that the bass does a lot more by not really being heard than when it is heard. I’m not saying that a bass line that really stands out in a song is bad thing at all. But, take away the bass from songs where you don’t really notice it so much and the song will really become less interesting.
I agree with you. The thing with a lot of bass parts in pop, rock, metal, whatever, is they just stick to the root notes the guitar is playing, and you wouldn’t really notice if it was gone. Good bassists know how to walk around the frets, chuck in a few extra notes here and there, and add something to the song. It’s a strangely subconscious thing… those bass parts make a difference, and if they were gone, you’d notice… but when they are there, they don’t immediately or consciously stick out. They do make all the difference tho.
I generally hate show off bassists, ‘look how many notes I can slap in a second’. Primus and Mr Bungle are the exceptions… but clowns like Vic Wooten, for all their talent, don’t have an ounce of discretion or taste in their bodies.
The only show off bassist who could ever get away with it was Jaco Pastorius. Check out ‘Portrait of Tracy’ to see what I mean. I had never heard the bass played like that, or that beautifully, up until then.
But anyway, I always thought that the bass lines in a lot of Ministry songs were repetitive and monotonous, so to speak. That is not a bad thing, but it always seems like it would be difficult to keep playing that over and over for 5 or 6 minutes. I guess after years of doing it, it’s no big deal, but I played bass for awhile and my fingers would start doing their own thing after awhile of something like that. So, I give Barker props for being able to do that. Doesn’t make him a musical genius or anything but it is something I could never do so it is what it is.
Strangely, all the basslines he used for Ministry and RevCo, and I mean, EVERY one was oddly hypnotic. I remember listening to No Devotion with my sister in the car and she goes ‘It goes on a bit, but… you want more of it, it’s sort of mesmerising’. She hit the nail on the head with that one.