I think it’s interesting to see albums like this get some love 30 years later. Perhaps part of it is that prior to the advent of CD’s, MP3’s, etc. you had either vinyl records, or cassette tapes (eventually). With either of these formats, you were really at the mercy of an entire album. It just wasn’t super convenient to get up and pick up the needle on the phonograph and try to find the spot where the next track you liked started. Tapes, too — FFW, stop, play, nope! Keep going FFW, stop, play, nope! Keep going! FFW, stop, play, DAMMIT!!! I went too far!! (and with some of those stupid auto-reverse players it got really confusing too, as you never knew which way you were even going).
However, that all-or-nothing dynamic of the LP back in the day, really forced bands to put up a strong album from start to finish, and something that sort of made sense in context of the whole. Most of the albums from bands you dug that were from the 60’s or 70’s you can listen to from beginning to end. 8 or 9 solid monster tracks.
Now I’ll get a CD (or download) with like 18 tracks, and I’ll be happy if I like 3 or 4 songs. Pull those off and put 'em on an iPod and you can forget the rest of the crap even existed.
If Elder was put out in the last 10 years, how would it have been received? I’m thinking people might have been happy with the few gems on it and be totally apathetic to the rest because they would NEVER listen to it. It probably wouldn’t achieve such an epic turd status.
I miss the old days. I miss knowing what an actual ALBUM was, even. I can listen to all the Ozzy-era Sabbath albums start to finish. I know exactly what song is coming up next and how one flows into the other. And they are all amazing.
Ask me about “Last Sucker” . . . I honestly don’t know anything about 90% of the songs on there. If I play the CD I’ll play “Let’s Go” and maybe “Life is Good”, and then I’ll eject it to play 2 songs from some other album.
I suspect it will be something similar for the new Sabbath disc. Probably 2 or 3 songs I dig, and the rest I’ll never hear a second time.